Episodes

July 7, 2025

129: Oleander & Trapdoors

Lace up your mystery‑solving shoes, gang—Patreon pal Savannah has sent us to Charleston’s infamous Six‑Mile House, home of legends John and Lavinia Fisher! 💀 A cup of Lavinia’s “special” oleander tea and a midnight trap‑door ...
June 30, 2025

128: The Book No One Can Read

Ruh-roh, gang—we're cracking open one of the most puzzling mysteries in history! This week, Josh leads us deep into the weird, wild world of the Voynich Manuscript: a centuries-old book packed with bizarre plants, star charts...
June 23, 2025

127: Urban Legends Unleashed

Zoinks! Grab your flashlights, detectives—Shane’s taking us on a spine-tingling road trip through some of America’s most legendary urban legends. From the axe-wielding Bunny Man and Staten Island’s nightmarish Cropsey to Mary...
June 16, 2025

126: Haunts, Hassles & Hidden Legos

Ruh-roh! This week, the gang stumbles across some very overdue Christmas gifts—including custom LEGO doppelgängers that send them down memory lane. But it’s not all bricks and giggles… Shane shares his frustration with return...
June 9, 2025

125: Docs, Lies & Videotape

Jinkies! Kim’s unearthed a treasure trove of documentaries guaranteed to blow your mystery-loving minds! From lost art and long-lost kids to tech billionaires chasing immortality and eerie cold cases, this list has everything...
June 2, 2025

124: Echoes in the Hills: The Appalachian Sirens

Zoinks, Gang! Join Josh for a mesmerizing deep dive into the eerie folklore of the Appalachian sirens—those haunting voices said to lure travelers off the beaten path. Are they restless spirits echoing through the hollows, or...
May 29, 2025

123: When Art Meets Arson: The Crying Boy Curse

Zoinks, Gang! In this episode of Mystery Inc, we’re stepping into the smoldering urban legend of The Crying Boy—a mass-produced painting that seemingly refused to burn, no matter how many house fires it endured. Join us as we...
May 19, 2025

122: Poison Pen in Circleville

Zoinks, Gang—this one’s got more twists than a carnival pretzel! In this episode, Shane investigates the decades-long nightmare of anonymous letters that rocked a small Ohio town. From mysterious phone calls and suspicious ca...
May 12, 2025

121: Secrets Beneath the Vatican

Zoinks, gang—Shane’s off chasing sunshine somewhere, so Josh and Kim are rolling up their sleeves to explore the spooky catacombs under Vatican City! These hidden tunnels hold secrets older than your grandma’s fruitcake, and ...
May 5, 2025

120: Sweet Secrets: The Vanished Candy Heiress

Zoinks, gang! With Shane and Betty White the Cavapoo vacationing in sunny Florida, Josh and Kim are on the case—and they’re sinking their sweet tooth into the baffling disappearance of candy heiress Helen Brach. This mystery ...
April 28, 2025

119: Visit from the Van Meter Fiend

Zoinks, Gang! We’re flying straight into a 1903 Iowa legend—meet the Van Meter Visitor! Part bat, part pterosaur, and maybe part interdimensional traveler, this stinky, winged fiend had townsfolk armed and nervous. Shane, Jos...
April 21, 2025

118: Cursed and Coffin’

Like, zoinks! This week, the Mystery Inc. gang cracks open the dusty door to one of the spookiest tales in ancient history—the curse of King Tut’s tomb! From mysteriously falling archaeologists to rumors of ancient booby trap...
April 14, 2025

117: Talking Walls & Bottomless Pits

Zoinks, Gang! Join Shane and Kim for a spine-tingling double feature exploring the quirky scribbles and possible hauntings at Haile Homestead, plus a descent into the legendary Devil’s Millhopper sinkhole. Along the way, we s...
April 7, 2025

116: Terror in Gainesville

Zoinks, Gang! In this episode, we explore the chilling true-crime story of the ‘Gainesville Ripper,’ who terrorized a Florida college town in 1990. With Shane and Kim at the helm (and Josh temporarily sidelined by a pulled ba...
March 31, 2025

115: Bones at Fox Hollow: The Baumeister Mystery

Jinkies, gang! This week, Kim takes us right into our own backyard of Indiana, unraveling the chilling mystery of Herbert Baumeister—an Indianapolis businessman whose peaceful Fox Hollow Farm hid a sinister secret. When men f...
March 24, 2025

114: Sacred Stones & Spooky Echoes: Barabar Unveiled

Zoinks, gang! This week, Shane’s Mystery takes us deep into the rocky hills of Bihar, India, where we’ll explore the ancient Barabar Caves—some of the oldest rock-cut wonders around. We’ll uncover hidden inscriptions from Emp...
March 13, 2025

113: Zoinks, I’ve Been Here Before! Josh’s Past Life Adventure

Zoinks, gang! In this mind-boggling episode, Josh delves into the eerie world of past life regression and reincarnation, sharing his own out-of-this-world experiences. We’ll investigate how hidden memories might uncover ancie...
March 10, 2025

112: The Juice is Loose: Did OJ Get Away With Murder?

Jinkies! This case has more twists than a highway chase in a white Bronco! Kim takes the Mystery Inc. gang deep into the trial of the century —the one and only OJ Simpson. Did the former football star really commit the crime ...
March 4, 2025

111: The Mysterious Vanishing of Marshal Iwaasa

Zoinks! This mystery is a real brain-boggler, gang! Marshal Iwaasa, a tech-savvy 26-year-old, vanished into thin air, and the only clue left behind was his burned-up truck deep in the eerie forests of British Columbia! What h...
Feb. 25, 2025

110: The Moon-Eyed Mystery: Who’s Hiding in the Appalachian Shadows?

Like, gang, get ready for a mystery straight outta the misty mountains of Appalachia! This week, Josh takes us deep into the legend of the Moon-Eyed People —a strange, pale-eyed race said to have roamed the hills long before ...
Feb. 18, 2025

109: Jerry! Jerry! The Wild Rise and Fall of a Talk Show Legend

Zoinks! Buckle up, gang, because this mystery is wilder than a late-night talk show brawl! This week, Kim takes us on a deep dive into the outrageous rise and scandalous history of The Jerry Springer Show . From Jerry's early...
Feb. 11, 2025

108: The Oakville Blobs: Mystery from the Sky

Zoinks, gang! Today, we’re heading to the small town of Oakville, Washington, where in 1994, something truly bizarre rained down from the sky—gelatinous, translucent blobs! Officer David Lacey first noticed them when his wind...
Feb. 4, 2025

107: The Witchcraft Murder: Who Killed Charles Walton?

Zoinks, gang! Grab your magnifying glass and your ghost-hunting gear, because Kim is leading us deep into the English countryside for a mystery that’ll make your hair stand on end! In 1945, an elderly farmhand named Charles W...
Jan. 28, 2025

106: Get a Load of This Wood!

Zoinks! In this tree-riffic episode, our pal Josh unearths the spooky secrets of these towering green giants and their eerie connections with humans. Jinkies, who knew trees could chat with each other through a hidden mycorrh...